The DeFi Education Fund, a crypto advocacy group, has recently called on the US Department of Justice (DOJ) to reconsider its approach to holding DeFi protocol developers accountable for users’ actions. In a blog post published by Andreessen Horowitz (A16z) on Feb. 4, co-authors Miller Whitehouse-Levine and Amanda Tuminelli from the DeFi Education Fund argued that developers should not be held liable for how their software is used, drawing parallels to car manufacturers not being responsible for drivers’ actions.
The authors emphasized that targeting developers under laws such as Section 1960 could set harmful precedents and expand legal risks across the crypto industry. They stressed the importance of distinguishing between those who create technology and those who actively control it, warning that misplacing liability could hinder technological advancement and discourage innovation in the DeFi sector.
One key point raised by the authors was the need for regulatory clarity in how laws such as the Money Transmitting license are interpreted. They highlighted the contrast between transactions on centralized exchanges, where users relinquish control of their funds to the platform, and DeFi protocols, where users retain full control over their assets. This distinction is crucial for understanding regulatory implications.
The authors called for clearer legal guidelines, particularly in defining custody and control within financial regulations. They argued that a well-defined legal framework would reduce uncertainty and support responsible innovation in the DeFi space. They urged industry stakeholders and lawmakers to collaborate in ensuring that the law accurately reflects concepts of custody and control, whether through market structure bills, broker reporting obligations, or reforms to Section 1960.
In conclusion, the DeFi Education Fund’s advocacy for a more nuanced approach to holding DeFi protocol developers accountable for users’ actions underscores the need for regulatory clarity and responsible innovation in the evolving crypto landscape. By fostering a better understanding of the roles and responsibilities of developers and users within decentralized networks, policymakers can support the growth and maturation of the DeFi sector in a sustainable and compliant manner.